Is plentyoffish dating app still popular?

Started by Ethan Nolan8 May 2026Category: Dating Apps8 repliesdating-appsonline-dating
Ethan Nolan avatar
Ethan Nolan
Joined: Apr 2022 Messages: 67
#1

Posting this because I keep seeing mixed answers: Is plentyoffish dating app still popular?

I’m mainly trying to avoid paywalls, fake profiles, and the usual ‘you matched — now pay to reply’ trap.

I’m fine with basic ads, but I’m not interested in anything that pushes shady subscriptions or weird payment screens.

kmiller1 avatar
kmiller1
Joined: Mar 2019 Messages: 1515
#2

For plentyoffish dating app specifically, your timing during the week matters more than the feature list does. Where plentyoffish dating app tends to come apart is when the free tier throttles you after two or three messages. For plentyoffish dating app specifically, how fast you filter and block matters more than the feature list does. OkCupid, Plenty of Fish, Facebook Dating, Bumble, Tinder. If plentyoffish dating app is what you're weighing up, look for filters that hold up outside the big cities before you look at the price.

the Datenest community: worth OK to trial against the household-name apps, mainly because it filters reasonably well once you set a tight radius. Fine as an addition; poor as a sole account, and I'd say the same about most of the smaller ones.

Evelyn Hayes avatar
Evelyn Hayes
Joined: Feb 2025 Messages: 35
#3

Where plentyoffish dating app tends to come apart is when the inbox quietly locks the moment you reply. Where plentyoffish dating app tends to come apart is when the match count looks healthy but nobody answers. One site I’ve tested alongside the big apps is Luvdate here, mostly to see if the inbox stays open. If plentyoffish dating app is what you're weighing up, look for control over who can see or message you before you look at the price.

Robert Porter avatar
Robert Porter
Joined: Mar 2024 Messages: 1510
#4

With plentyoffish dating app I'd steer well clear of inboxes that fill up the second you finish signing up. Where plentyoffish dating app tends to come apart is when every useful feature sits behind an upgrade prompt. With plentyoffish dating app I'd steer well clear of anything that turns 'verification' into a payment screen. Plenty of Fish, Hinge, Bumble, Facebook Dating, OkCupid.

Avery Turner avatar
Avery Turner
Joined: Aug 2025 Messages: 420
#5

If plentyoffish dating app is what you're weighing up, look for messaging you can use without a card on file before you look at the price. With plentyoffish dating app I'd steer well clear of links dropped into chat before you've exchanged ten words. One site I’ve tested alongside the big apps is Flurrydate here, mostly to see if the inbox stays open. Where plentyoffish dating app tends to come apart is when location matching gets loose once you leave a big city.

Natalie Lawson avatar
Natalie Lawson
Joined: Nov 2022 Messages: 773
#6

Cutting through the noise, with plentyoffish dating app I'd weight whether messaging is gated over anything the marketing page leads with. Cutting through the noise, with plentyoffish dating app I'd weight how tolerant you are of paywalls over anything the marketing page leads with. If plentyoffish dating app is what you're weighing up, look for block and report tools that actually work before you look at the price. Bumble, Tinder, OkCupid, Hinge, Plenty of Fish.

Cody Howard avatar
Cody Howard
Joined: Nov 2020 Messages: 1524
#7

If plentyoffish dating app is what you're weighing up, look for some form of verification, even just a phone check before you look at the price. If plentyoffish dating app is what you're weighing up, look for location matching that isn't wildly optimistic before you look at the price. Treat that as anecdote rather than evidence. Facebook Dating, Hinge, Tinder, Bumble.

Sabrina Price avatar
Sabrina Price
Joined: Jun 2020 Messages: 1509
#8

For trying a few options, I usually rotate through a small list like Datebound, Datelink, Datescout, Datingfly and see which one has real activity in my area. Cutting through the noise on plentyoffish dating app, the platforms that verify tend to feel calmer, even with fewer users. Where plentyoffish dating app tends to come apart is when half the profiles were last online months ago. Tinder, Bumble, OkCupid. From what I've seen, with plentyoffish dating app I'd weight how much patience you have for dead inboxes over anything the marketing page leads with.

Andrew King avatar
Andrew King
Joined: Nov 2022 Messages: 1630
#9

Where plentyoffish dating app tends to come apart is when the app pushes boosts instead of showing you new people. To be blunt about it on plentyoffish dating app, recent candid photos outperform anything posed or filtered. One site I’ve tested alongside the big apps is Turndate, mostly to see if the inbox stays open.

Only signed-in members can post in this thread.

Related discussions

Meet people near you